← Back to comparison

What Your VPN Really Costs After Year One: 2026 Renewal Prices

The price on the sign-up page is the cheapest your VPN will ever be. Here is the rest of the bill.

Disclosure: The ‘Claim Deal’ buttons on this page are affiliate links. As an independent technician, I may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. Prices are in USD, checked 31 October 2026.

The short answer

  • Biggest jump: NordVPN Basic. Its renewal year costs $139.08, which is 3.3 times its first-term yearly average.
  • Smallest jump: Private Internet Access. It renews at $79 every 3 years, about $26.33 a year.
  • In between: ExpressVPN Basic renews at $99.95 and Proton VPN Plus at $83.88 a year. Surfshark shows the applicable renewal price at checkout rather than publishing one fixed figure.
  • Short stay? Month to month can be cheaper if you need a VPN for under about 4 to 8 months.

How the intro price works

The low monthly figure is a long plan divided into months.

  • You pay the whole first term upfront, such as $94.23 for 27 months.
  • The plan then renews on its own, at the provider’s standard rate.
  • That renewal is billed yearly (or every 3 years at PIA), not monthly.

What each VPN costs per year

First-term price averaged over 12 months, against what a renewal year costs.

Swipe sideways to compare →

Prices in USDIntro, per yearAfter renewal, per yearRenewal vs intro
NordVPN Basic$41.88$139.08+232%
ExpressVPN Basic$35.88$99.95+179%
Surfshark Starter$29.88Shown at checkoutNot calculated
Proton VPN Plus$41.88$83.88+100%
Private Internet Access$24.31$26.33+8%

How much you will have paid

Cash paid by the end of year 1, 3 and 5, counting every renewal that starts before then. The last column is month to month for 5 years.

Swipe sideways to compare →

Prices in USDYear 1Year 3Year 5Month to month, 5 years
NordVPN Basic$94.23$233.31$511.47$899.40
ExpressVPN Basic$83.72$183.67$383.57$899.40
Surfshark Starter$67.23Varies; check renewal at checkoutVaries; check renewal at checkout$987.00
Proton VPN Plus$83.76$167.64$335.40$599.40
Private Internet Access$79.00$79.00$158.00$717.00

Our arithmetic from published prices. Surfshark renewal is not included in the year 3 or year 5 total because the applicable amount is shown at checkout and can vary. Renewals are billed when a term ends, so a payment can cover time past the year shown.

When month to month wins

If you need a VPN for fewer months than the last column, month to month costs less than the long plan.

Swipe sideways to compare →

Prices in USDPer monthFirst termBreak-even
NordVPN Basic$14.99$94.236.3 months
ExpressVPN Basic$12.99$83.726.4 months
Surfshark Starter$16.45$67.234.1 months
Proton VPN Plus$9.99$83.768.4 months
Private Internet Access$11.95$79.006.6 months

How to avoid the jump

  1. Put the renewal date in your calendarSet it for 30 days before, while you can still decide.
  2. Check your account settingsLook for the auto-renew switch and the renewal price shown there.
  3. Compare before you renewA different VPN’s intro deal can beat your own renewal.
  4. Know the catch with switchingCancelling and signing up again may not be allowed, and some guarantees cover new customers only. Read the terms first.

Which to pick, by how long you will stay

A few months

Proton VPN costs $9.99 a month, the lowest monthly price here, with a free plan as a fallback.

Claim Proton VPN Deal
2 to 3 years

Surfshark Starter is listed at $2.49 a month on the current 27-month offer. Check checkout for its applicable renewal rate.

Claim Surfshark Deal
3 years or more

PIA is $2.03 a month on its 3-year plan and renews at $79 every 3 years.

Claim PIA Deal
Antivirus bundled in

NordVPN Complete and Prime include next-generation antivirus / anti-malware features. Complete is listed at $4.49 a month on the current 27-month offer.

Claim NordVPN Deal

Provider prices checked 31 October 2026. Rates can vary by location, tax and promotion. Surfshark presents the applicable renewal rate at checkout instead of publishing one universal price. Renewal totals and comparisons that depend on a fixed Surfshark renewal are omitted.

Where these numbers come from

  • NordVPN, ExpressVPN, Surfshark, Proton VPN and PIA: official pricing/support pages, checked 31 October 2026.
  • Surfshark’s renewal amount is displayed at checkout and varies by offer and region, so fixed long-term renewal totals are not estimated.
  • Yearly and 5-year figures: our arithmetic from those prices.

Questions people ask

Why does my VPN cost more at renewal?

The low monthly price is a long plan divided into months. You pay the whole first term upfront. When it ends, the plan renews at the provider’s standard rate, which is usually several times higher per month.

Can I keep the intro price?

Not by staying on the same plan. Some people cancel and sign up again for a new deal, but a provider’s terms may not allow it, and a refund guarantee may cover new customers only. Check the terms before you rely on it.

Is month to month ever cheaper?

Yes, for short stays. Month to month costs less than a long plan if you need the VPN for roughly four to eight months, depending on the provider. See the break-even table above.

Not sure which one?

Take the 3-question quiz, or see every price side by side.

Compare the top VPNs →