Best VPNs compared: NordVPN, ExpressVPN, Surfshark, Proton VPN and PIA

Affiliate disclosure: The ‘Claim Deal’ buttons and quiz results on this site are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. I’m an independent computer technician, I don’t accept paid sponsorships from VPN brands, and commissions don’t change my review outcomes. Prices are in USD. Read the full disclosure.

Quick picks

Last checked: 31 October 2026 · Prices in USD

Short on time? Here is who each VPN suits best.

Best overall: NordVPN

Ranked first by Security.org and top pick at TechRadar and Tom’s Guide.

Read the review →
Best value: Surfshark

The lowest 2-year price we list, at $2.49 a month, with unlimited devices.

Read the review →
Best for privacy: Proton VPN

Open-source, audited apps, a Swiss base and a free plan.

Read the review →
Easiest to use: ExpressVPN

Praised for its simple app by TechRadar and Tom’s Guide.

Read the review →
Lowest long-term price: PIA

$2.03 a month on its 3-year plan, with unlimited devices.

Read the review →

Best VPNs in the US Compared: Side-by-Side Review

We checked prices on 31 October 2026. These entry-level rates are shown in USD and are subject to change based on your local US state tax rates at checkout.

The VPNs below share the basics: strong encryption, apps for every major device, and a money-back guarantee. The differences are in the details below.

The “Claim Deal” buttons below are affiliate links. Read our disclosure.

Swipe sideways to compare →

NordVPNExpressVPNSurfsharkProton VPNPIA
Best forAll-round speed and extrasSimplicity and reliabilityHouseholds with many devicesPrivacy-first usersLowest long-term price, plus advanced settings
DevicesUp to 10 devices10 to 14 devices, depending on planUnlimited devices10 on paid plans, 1 on the free planUnlimited
US Streaming AccessNot tested by us. Services block VPNs at times.Apps for Fire TV, Android TV and Apple TVApps for Fire TV, Android TV and Apple TVApps for Fire TV, Android TV and Apple TV, on unlimited devicesStreaming is on paid plans only. Test it inside the refund windowSmart DNS lets you change location from a smart TV
US Server CountServers inside the United States2,450 servers in 55 US locations, all 50 statesAll 50 states, 62 US locations. Server count not published600+ servers in 24 US locationsNot published. Reviewers count roughly 3,500 to 6,000Servers in all 50 states. Count not published
Dedicated US IPA fixed IP only you useAdd-on. US locations availableAdd-on, or included with Express Pro. US locations availableAdd-on. Check US locations at checkoutBusiness customers onlyAdd-on. US locations available
ProtocolsNordLynx, with post-quantum encryptionLightway, with post-quantum protectionWireGuard, OpenVPNSecure protocols, kill switchWireGuard and OpenVPN, both open source
ExtrasScam and phishing protection, Dark Web Monitor; higher plans add password manager and 1 TB cloud storageAd and malicious-site blocking, email relay; higher plans add a password manager and identity tools. No antivirusAd and cookie pop-up blocker, split tunneling, MultiHop; higher plans add antivirus and data-leak alertsSecure Core, NetShield ad blocker, open-source apps, free planAd, tracker and malware blocker, multi-hop, obfuscation, split tunneling, port forwarding; Antivirus and dedicated IP add-ons
Antivirus on the entry planWhat you get nativelyNot on Basic. Starts on CompleteNo antivirus on any planNot on Starter. Starts on OneNo antivirus. NetShield blocks malware sitesOptional add-on
Refund window30 days30 days, new users only30 days30 days on paid plans30 days, new subscribers only
Get it ClaimNordVPN Deal ClaimExpressVPN Deal ClaimSurfshark Deal ClaimProton VPN DealClaimPIA Deal

Features and plan details last checked on 31 October 2026. Device limits and extras vary by plan, and providers change them often. US server counts come from NordVPN’s and Surfshark’s US server pages and a 2026 Gizmodo guide. Dedicated IP details come from provider pages and reviewer guides.

// vpn_finder v1

Find your VPN in 3 questions

No email needed. Prices in USD, checked 31 October 2026.

Best for your situation

Pick by what you actually need. Prices in USD, see the table below for details.

Secure travel & public Wi-Fi

Best for Secure Travel & Public Wi-Fi

Our pick: NordVPN

  • Top-ranked overall by Security.org, TechRadar and Tom’s Guide
  • 30-day refund that covers any customer
  • Up to 10 devices, with apps for phone, laptop and TV
Claim NordVPN Deal →

Read the full travel guide →

US accounts from abroad

Best for Using Your US Accounts Abroad

Our pick: Surfshark

  • 600+ servers across 24 US locations
  • Unlimited devices for the whole family
  • Lowest 2-year price we list, $2.49 a month

Banks and streaming apps may still block VPN connections. Test inside the refund window.

Claim Surfshark Deal →
Sports fans

Sports Fans: Check This Before You Pay

No VPN can promise this

  • Blackouts are set by league and broadcaster rights
  • Services often block VPN servers, and using one can break their terms
  • Travelling? Use a VPN to reach your own subscription, and test it inside the refund window
Compare refund windows →

What they cost

Entry-level prices in US dollars, before US state and local sales tax, checked on 31 October 2026. The low headline rates need you to pay for the whole term upfront, and every one of them rises at renewal.

Prices last checked: 31 October 2026 · All prices in US dollars (USD)

Prices rise at renewal. The low rates below are not billed monthly. You pay the whole first term upfront, then the plan renews under its current terms. Published annual renewal prices include NordVPN Basic at $139.08, ExpressVPN Basic at $99.95 and Proton VPN Plus at $83.88. PIA lists $79 every 3 years. Surfshark shows the applicable renewal price at checkout; it does not publish one fixed renewal amount on its pricing page. Month to month costs $9.99 to $16.45 for the entry plans.

Swipe sideways to compare →

Prices in USDNordVPNExpressVPNSurfsharkProton VPNPIA
Entry planBasicBasicStarterVPN PlusOne VPN plan
Long plan, per month2-year plans; PIA is 3 years. Not billed monthly$3.49billed $94.23 upfront for 27 months$2.99billed $83.72 upfront for 28 months$2.49billed $67.23 upfront for 27 months$3.49billed $83.76 upfront for 24 months$2.033-year plan, billed $79 upfront for 39 months
Price after the intro termCheck checkout for renewal terms$139.08 a yearabout $11.59 a month$99.95 a yearabout $8.33 a monthShown at checkoutvaries by offer and location$83.88 a yearabout $6.99 a month$79 every 3 yearsabout $2.19 a month
Month-to-month$14.99$12.99$16.45$9.99$11.95
Cost per year, intro rateFirst term averaged over 12 months$41.88$35.88$29.88$41.88$24.31
Cost per year, after renewalPIA: $79 over 3 years$139.08$99.95Not published$83.88$26.33
Cost per year, month to monthMonthly price times 12$179.88$155.88$197.40$119.88$143.40
Higher plans, long plan, per monthComplete $4.49
Prime $7.49
Advanced $4.49
Express Pro $7.49
One $2.49
One+ $3.99
Proton Unlimited $7.99One plan, with Antivirus and Dedicated IP add-ons
Antivirus / security bundleComplete and Prime include next-gen antivirus / anti-malware featuresNo antivirus includedOne and One+ include antivirus; Starter does notNetShield blocks ads, trackers and malware at DNS level; not a full antivirusOptional Windows antivirus add-on
Free planNoNoNoYes, Proton FreeNo
Money-back guarantee30 days30 days, new users only30 days30 days, paid plans30 days, new subscribers only
  • Cheapest overall: Private Internet Access, at $2.03 a month on its 3-year plan ($79 upfront for 39 months). Among 2-year introductory offers, Surfshark Starter is currently $2.49 a month.
  • Watch the monthly plans: month to month, NordVPN Basic costs $14.99, ExpressVPN Basic $12.99, Surfshark Starter $16.45 and PIA $11.95, against $3.49, $2.99 and $2.49 on the 2-year offers and $2.03 on PIA’s 3-year offer.
  • Yearly view: staying month to month costs $119.88 to $197.40 a year, against $24.31 to $41.88 a year in the first term. Yearly figures are our arithmetic from the provider prices above.
  • Higher tiers add extras such as password managers, identity monitoring and cloud storage. If you only want a VPN, the entry plan is enough.
  • Your price may differ: subscription and renewal rates are subject to change based on your location, US state and local sales tax, and active promotions. The provider’s checkout page shows your final price.

Provider pricing checked 31 October 2026. Surfshark displays the applicable renewal rate during checkout, and current promotional prices may vary by location, tax and offer. Introductory billing periods differ: these monthly equivalents are not monthly subscriptions. Confirm your final price and renewal terms at checkout.

The reviews

All prices below are in US dollars (USD).

NordVPN

Fast, feature-rich, and hard to fault.

NordVPN is a strong default choice. Its NordLynx protocol and large server network, with thousands of servers in 225+ locations, keep speeds high.

It sells Basic, Complete and Prime plans. The current US plan comparison lists next-generation antivirus and anti-malware protection in Complete and Prime; Basic does not include those higher-tier security extras. Higher tiers also add an ad and tracker blocker, password manager and cloud storage, with identity protection features on Prime.

Compare NordVPN vs ExpressVPN →

Read the full NordVPN review →

What we like

  • Ranked first by Security.org
  • Servers in 225+ locations
  • Three plans with extras up to identity insurance

What to watch

  • Basic renews at $139.08 a year after the intro term
  • Basic plan skips the password manager and ad blocker

ExpressVPN

The one that just works.

ExpressVPN focuses on a clean app and dependable connections, with servers in 113 countries. It sells three plans, Basic, Advanced and Express Pro, which allow 10, 12 and 14 devices.

Advanced adds a password manager and identity tools with up to $3 million of theft insurance. Express Pro adds a dedicated IP and up to $5 million of insurance.

None of the plans includes antivirus. It suits people who want to press one button and forget about it.

Compare NordVPN vs ExpressVPN →

Read the full ExpressVPN review →

What we like

  • Simple, polished apps
  • Servers in 113 countries
  • Three plans, up to 14 devices

What to watch

  • Basic renews at $99.95 a year after the intro term
  • Fewer tweaks for advanced users

Surfshark

Best value for a busy household.

Surfshark lets you connect an unlimited number of devices on one subscription, which is hard to beat for families and shared homes. It has 4500+ servers in 100 countries and an audited no-logs policy.

It sells three plans, Starter, One and One+. The One plan adds antivirus, data-leak alerts and scam protection, and One+ adds identity theft coverage and data removal through Incogni.

See Surfshark alternatives →

What we like

  • Unlimited simultaneous devices
  • 4500+ servers in 100 countries
  • Audited no-logs policy
  • Lowest 2-year starting price

What to watch

  • Identity theft coverage is limited to US residents
  • Renewal rate is shown at checkout and can vary

Proton VPN

The privacy specialist.

Proton VPN comes from the team behind Proton Mail and is built around privacy. It is Swiss-based, has a no-logs policy, and its apps are open source and independently audited.

Secure Core adds an extra hop for more protection. The free plan has no data limits but covers 1 device at medium speed.

The paid VPN Plus plan covers 10 devices, adds streaming, P2P and an ad and malware blocker, with 20,000+ servers in 140+ countries.

What we like

  • Open-source, audited apps
  • Swiss-based company
  • A free plan with no data limits

What to watch

  • Free plan is 1 device at medium speed
  • Streaming and P2P need a paid plan

Private Internet Access

Cheapest long-term price, packed with advanced settings.

Private Internet Access (PIA) is built around low prices and control. One subscription covers unlimited devices, and its apps are open source.

Its RAM-only servers cover 113 countries, on a 10 Gbps network. It sells a single VPN plan with no feature tiers, plus an optional Windows antivirus add-on and Dedicated IP.

Key features

  • WireGuard and OpenVPN, both open source
  • Advanced kill switch and DNS leak protection
  • MACE blocker for ads, trackers and malware at DNS level
  • Multi-hop and obfuscation
  • Split tunneling
  • Port forwarding, and P2P on every server
  • Unlimited bandwidth
  • Auto-connect rules by network type
  • Router support, and Smart DNS for smart TVs
  • 24/7 support and a free email breach monitor

What we like

  • Unlimited devices on one plan
  • Lowest long-term price, $2.03 a month
  • Many advanced settings, all included

What to watch

  • The best price needs a 3-year commitment
  • Month to month costs $11.95
  • Guarantee is for new subscribers only

Best VPN for streaming

A VPN can let you watch your home library while travelling, or reach libraries from other regions. Streaming services work hard to block VPN servers, so what works changes week to week.

Best overall: NordVPNFast connections handle HD and 4K, and the large server list gives you more to try when one gets blocked.
Most reliable: ExpressVPNKnown for consistent performance and a simple app, which suits people who want it to work without fiddling.
Best for the whole family: SurfsharkUnlimited devices means every TV, phone and tablet at home can be covered on one plan.
Best for privacy: Proton VPNA strong privacy record. Streaming support is on its paid plans, so test your services during the refund window.

Before you stream: Using a VPN to watch content not licensed for your region may break a streaming service's terms. No VPN can guarantee access to every service, so use the money-back window to test the ones you care about.

Guides and comparisons

Best VPN for travel

Five VPNs compared for trips: costs, renewals, devices and a Wi-Fi routine.

Read the guide →
VPN renewal prices

What each VPN really costs after year one, with 1-, 3- and 5-year totals.

Read the guide →
US bank account from abroad

How to avoid a lock-out while traveling, and where a VPN helps.

Read the guide →
VPN vs. antivirus

What each one protects, how they overlap, and how Intego ONE compares.

Read the guide →
What does a VPN actually do?

How a VPN works, what it can and can’t do, and how to choose one.

Read the guide →
Set up a VPN on a Smart TV or Fire TV Stick

Step-by-step for Fire TV, Android TV, Apple TV, plus workarounds for Samsung, LG and Roku.

Read the guide →
Surfshark alternatives

When to look elsewhere, and how NordVPN, ExpressVPN and Proton VPN compare.

Read the guide →
NordVPN vs ExpressVPN

Price, devices, features and refunds, head to head.

Read the comparison →

Which one should you pick?

Start with what you care about most.

You want speed and extrasChoose NordVPN.
You want the easiest setupChoose ExpressVPN.
You have lots of devices or a tight budgetChoose Surfshark.
You care most about privacyChoose Proton VPN.
You want the lowest price with unlimited devicesChoose Private Internet Access.

A VPN in plain words

A VPN wraps your internet traffic in encryption and sends it through a server run by the VPN company. Websites see the server's address instead of yours, and anyone on your network, such as a café or hotel Wi-Fi, cannot read what you send.

Read the full VPN guide → Take the 3-question VPN quiz

Disclosure: Some links on this site are affiliate links. If you click through and buy a VPN, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. This does not change our review outcomes or opinions. Pricing and promotions change often; please verify current details on each provider’s site before buying.

Questions people ask

Does a VPN make me anonymous?

No. A VPN hides your traffic from your network and your internet provider, and it swaps your real IP address for the VPN server’s.

That is privacy, not anonymity. Websites can still recognise you through the accounts you log in to, cookies and your browser’s fingerprint, and the VPN company can see your traffic unless it has a no-logs policy you trust.

Look for one that outside auditors have checked.

If you want more protection, some providers route traffic through two servers, such as Surfshark’s MultiHop and Proton VPN’s Secure Core. For real anonymity you would also need to change how you browse, not just add a VPN.

Will a VPN slow down my internet?

A little, because your traffic takes a detour and has to be encrypted. On a good provider the slowdown is small.

In Security.org’s 2026 tests, Proton VPN cut download speeds by about 8% at most, and it rated NordVPN and Surfshark similarly.

You can keep speeds high by connecting to a server close to you, using the provider’s fastest protocol (NordLynx on NordVPN, Lightway on ExpressVPN), and using a wired or strong Wi-Fi connection. The free Proton plan runs at medium speed by design.

Is using a VPN legal?

In most countries, yes. A small number of countries restrict or ban VPNs, so check the rules where you live and where you are travelling.

A VPN does not make illegal activity legal.

Also read the terms of any service you use it with. Streaming services often forbid VPN use to watch content that is not licensed in your region, and they may block VPN connections.

Is there a free VPN worth using?

Proton VPN is the only one of these four with a permanent free plan. It has no data limits and no ads, but it covers one device at a time, runs at medium speed, and connects to servers in 10 countries that are chosen for you.

Streaming and P2P need a paid plan.

NordVPN, ExpressVPN and Surfshark have no free plan, but each has a 30-day money-back guarantee, so you can test one and get a refund. ExpressVPN limits its guarantee to new users.

Surfshark also mentions a free trial on its site, so check whether one is available for your device.

Be careful with other free VPNs. Some earn money by tracking your activity or showing ads, which defeats the purpose.

Can I get my money back?

All four offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, but ExpressVPN limits it to new users. The others apply it to their paid plans.

Read the current terms before you buy, since they can change.

Compare the top VPNs →