← Back to comparison

Best Surfshark alternatives

Surfshark is good value to start, but it is not right for everyone. Here is where NordVPN, ExpressVPN, Proton VPN and Private Internet Access do better, and where they cost more.

Choosing mainly for a Fire TV Stick? See our device-specific guide to Surfshark alternatives for Firestick, including Fire OS and Vega OS app support.

Disclosure: The “Claim Deal” buttons on this page are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you buy, at no extra cost to you. Prices were checked on 31 October 2026 and are in US dollars (USD).

Why people look for an alternative

Month to month is costly

Surfshark Starter is $16.45 a month, the highest entry monthly price of the five we compare.

Check the renewal before subscribing

The current Starter offer is $2.49 a month for 27 months. Surfshark displays the applicable renewal rate at checkout, so compare the full term and renewal amount before buying.

Extras sit in higher tiers

Starter is the VPN plus Alternative ID. Antivirus and alerts need One, and identity coverage needs One+, which is limited to US residents.

Other picks lead some rankings

Security.org ranks NordVPN first and Surfshark second, and TechRadar and Tom’s Guide pick NordVPN as best overall or best for most people.

The alternatives

NordVPN

Best all-round alternative

Choose it if you want a top-ranked, well-rounded VPN and a plan that adds antivirus, a password manager and cloud storage as you move up.

Trade-off: it allows up to 10 devices, not unlimited, and Basic renews at $139.08 a year.

From $3.49 a month on the 2-year plan, billed $94.23 upfront for 27 months.

Claim NordVPN Deal

ExpressVPN

Best if you want it simple

Choose it if you want an easy app and more devices than Nord: 10 to 14 depending on plan. Reviewers rate it for ease of use.

Trade-off: the guarantee is for new users only, and Basic renews at $99.95 a year.

From $2.99 a month on the 2-year plan, billed $83.72 upfront for 28 months.

Claim ExpressVPN Deal

Proton VPN

Best for privacy and a free option

Choose it if privacy is your priority. It has open-source, audited apps, a Swiss base, and the only free plan of the five, with no data limits.

Trade-off: the free plan is 1 device at medium speed, and streaming and P2P need a paid plan.

From $3.49 a month on the 2-year plan, billed $83.76 upfront for 24 months.

Claim Proton VPN Deal

Private Internet Access

Best for the lowest long-term price

Choose it if you want the cheapest long plan, no device limit, and advanced settings such as multi-hop, obfuscation and port forwarding.

Trade-off: the best price needs a 3-year commitment, and the guarantee is for new subscribers only.

From $2.03 a month on the 3-year plan, billed $79 upfront for 39 months.

Claim PIA Deal

Surfshark and its alternatives at a glance

Swipe sideways to compare →

Prices in USDSurfsharkNordVPNExpressVPNProton VPNPIA
Long plan, per monthPIA is 3 years$2.49$3.49$2.99$3.49$2.03
Billed upfront$67.23, 27 months$94.23, 27 months$83.72, 28 months$83.76, 24 months$79, 39 months
After the intro termShown at checkout$139.08 a year$99.95 a year$83.88 a year$79 every 3 years
Month-to-month$16.45$14.99$12.99$9.99$11.95
DevicesUnlimitedUp to 1010 to 14, by plan10 on paid plansUnlimited
Free planNoNoNoYesNo
Money-back guarantee30 days30 days30 days, new users only30 days, paid plans30 days, new subscribers only

Entry-level plans, prices in US dollars, checked 31 October 2026. Intro rates are billed upfront and rise at renewal. Subscription and renewal rates are subject to change based on your location, US state and local sales tax, and active promotions, so confirm the final price at checkout.

When to stay with Surfshark

Surfshark is still hard to beat if you have a big household, because it has no device limit, and so does Private Internet Access. It also has the lowest 2-year starting price we list, at $2.49 a month, though PIA is cheaper on its 3-year plan.

If those matter most to you, the alternatives above may not be worth switching for.

Claim Surfshark Deal

Switching without paying twice

  1. Start the new planPick a provider with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
  2. Test it for a week or twoUse it on your usual devices and streaming apps while you are still inside the refund window.
  3. Cancel Surfshark’s auto-renewalDo this in your account settings before the renewal date. Removing the app does not cancel the plan.

Want to see them side by side?

Compare features, devices and prices in one table.

Compare the top VPNs →